Signings have come and gone at Villa Park in the last five years, but it’s fair to say some have made more of an impact than others. 

When assessing a transfer, it’s important to consider four things: 

1) How much was forked out?

2) Did the club make a profit if they sold him on?

3) How much production did the club get out of him?

4) How much of a leader was he?

Considering all those things, it’s time to work out Villa’s best and worst signings of the last five years. 

You will vote in a series of one-on-one encounters – just choose the signing that you think was best.